13 Best Pizza Places in Hell’s Kitchen, NYC

Although the name “Hell’s Kitchen” might evoke images of gangsters and rampant crime, this Manhattan neighborhood has come a very long way since its seedier beginnings.

In the 1990s, Time Square got a more wholesome makeover, and Hell’s Kitchen followed suit. Today, this neighborhood is a thriving cultural hub full of some of the best restaurants in the entire city. Hell’s Kitchen pizza is now on the NYC pizza map!

Hot Homemade Pepperoni Pizza

Today, tourists actually go to Hell’s Kitchen to get some shopping done, visit a few museums, or even go kayaking. 

This new, family-friendly Hell’s Kitchen also boasts some of the best pizza restaurants in all of Manhattan. If you’re looking for a good, authentic pie or slice of pizza, these thirteen restaurants will undoubtedly hit the spot. From classic Italian pizza to inspired new favorites, Hell’s Kitchen is the place to go for good eating.

Check out my list of the best pizza in Hell’s Kitchen below!  

13. The Marshal 

622 10th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 977-1170
Visit Website

Visit the Manhattan Plaza Health Club and then walk three blocks down the street to The Marshal to reward yourself for a great workout.

This iconic, high-end pizza parlor is one of the top places to dine in all of Hell’s Kitchen. I love their macaroni and cheese. It’s loaded with several different kinds of cheese, corkscrew pasta, and baked to gooey perfection.

Their farmer’s market pizza is a great pick too, topped with local, fresh ingredients like tomatoes, mushrooms, and brussel sprouts. If you want to have your pizza and veggies too, this is a solid option.


12. Capizzi

547 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212) 695-6900
Visit Website

Capizzi is a cozy, welcoming place that will make you feel like you’re in a quaint town in Italy rather than the heart of Hell’s Kitchen. Right near the Port Authority, this restaurant is the place to go for some of the best pizza in Hell’s Kitchen.

All of their pies are great, but I love their mushroom slices. They don’t skimp on the mushrooms, and the ratio of topping to cheese is exceptional.

If you can save room for dessert, definitely do. Their guava pizza with cheese will knock your socks off. It’s not too sweet but is richly flavored and decadent.


11. BarDough

350 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (917)262-0543
Visit Website

BarDough is conveniently located right near New York Times Square. Walk down the street from the Hotel Riu Plaza, and you can’t miss it.

One thing that BarDough is absolutely known for is its service. They have some of the friendliest and best staff in all of New York. The food is pretty incredible as well.

I love the homemade bread at BarDough, specifically the calzones and garlic knots. Both are fluffy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Their pizzas are great, too, with thin crusts, the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese, and significant portions. 


10. Tavola 

488 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212)273-1181
Visit Website

Tavola is a block away from Arlo Midtown and is famous for its authentic, fresh Italian food and wood-fired pizzas. Although I certainly recommend any of their pizzas, I also know their grilled chicken with lemon herb marinade and eggplant parmigiana.

You can also get a vegan version of the eggplant parmigiana that tastes just as good as the original.

If you’re in the mood for pizza, check out their classic margherita with pomodoro sauce, plenty of basil, and two different types of cheeses.


9. Sacco Pizza

819 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 582-7765
Visit Website

Sacco Pizza is roughly two blocks away from Balsley Park and is well-known for its outstanding service and welcoming atmosphere. You will feel right at home the second that you step through the door at Sacco Pizza.

Of course, since Sacco Pizza is a Hell’s Kitchen treasure, you might be waiting a few minutes for your pie to arrive, but it’s all worth it in the end.

I love all of their classic pizzas, but what gets me through the door at Sacco Pizza are their garlic knots. Packed with garlicky flavor and cooked to perfection, you really can’t go wrong with them. 


9. Claudio Pizza & Pasta 

598 10th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212)586-3145
Visit Website

Two blocks from YOTEL New York, hungry tourists and locals will find Claudio Pizza & Pasta. If you’re looking for affordable, delicious fare, this is definitely the spot to go.

Their servings are large, they don’t skimp on quality, and you and your family will definitely leave happy. One thing that Claudio Pizza & Pasta is famous for is their service. Their staff is knowledgeable about the menu and so glad to help you in any way that they can.

I like their pepperoni and cheese pizza. The portions are excellent, with salty pepperoni, the right amount of sauce, and a good sprinkle of cheese. Claudio Pizza & Pasta also does a great New York-style pie with a thin, flavorful, crispy crust. 


8. B Side

370 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (646) 679-7225
Visit Website

B Side is a few blocks away from Hell’s Kitchen’s Gutenberg Playground and has been a local haunt for many years. B Side does tend to get a little bit popular, so be prepared to wait if you arrive when it’s busy.

It’s worth it, though. Their pizza is exceptionally good, with inspired toppings and excellent crust.  

B Side is known for its inventive pizzas. Although you can get good classics here, you might want to try some of their more off-beat pies.

The killer bee and carbonara pizzas are two of my favorites, and they work well with a side of brussel sprouts or a kale salad. Save room for chocolate pudding for dessert.


6. Corner Slice

600 11th Avenue at, W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 956-9339
Visit Website

Go right across the street from TCS Technological Cinevideo Services, and you’ll come across Corner Slice, a humble and tasty Hell’s Kitchen pizzeria that is extremely popular with the locals. So if you want to dine in style and experience an authentic taste of Manhattan, Corner Slice is the place to go.  

Their pepperoni is a true standout ingredient. It’s salty, a little spicy, and totally top-notch.

Of course, you can also get fresh, perfectly prepared vegetables, cheese, or any other number of toppings and flavors. The dough is a little bit thicker than your average pie and is reminiscent of a brioche rather than a pizza, which is a nice change from other parlors.


5. Bakers Pizza

754 10th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (917)262-0722
Visit Website

Bakers Pizza is adjacent to the 52nd Street Project Oasis Garden and specializes in authentic pizzas with some creative ingredients.

You can find typical pizzas, like cheese and pepperoni, at Bakers Pizza. You can also get a tasty vegan cheese pie or top your pie or slice with brussels sprouts, caramelized onion, jalapeno, homemade meatballs, sauteed mushrooms, and more.

Both the topping and pizza ingredients at Bakers Pizza are exceptionally high quality, and you can tell that they put them together with love. Order a custom pie, or create your own. Either way, you will not walk away hungry or disappointed. 


4. Nizza

630 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 956-1800
Visit Website

Walk a few blocks away from McCaffrey Playground, and you’ll find Nizza, a great pizzeria right in the heart of Hell’s Kitchen.

Locals know Nizza for its vast menu of traditional pies and gluten-free options. Their gluten-free pizzas taste just like the real thing, allowing those with dietary restrictions to enjoy fresh, authentic pizza with all the flavors they expect and want.

I love their quattro formaggi, or four cheese pizza. It’s loaded with an ample cheesy flavor that balances perfectly with the red sauce. Plus, it’s big enough for sharing. So make sure that you put Nizza on your “must visit” list next time you’re in Hell’s Kitchen.


3. Sullivan Street Bakery

533 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 265-5580
Visit Website

Sullivan Street Bakery is about two blocks from Bane Haunted House and is notable for its excellent baked goods, sandwiches, and of course, pizza.

Sullivan Street Bakery continues to be one of the top places to enjoy a fresh pie in Hell’s Kitchen because of the high quality of its ingredients.

Everything at Sullivan Street Bakery is fresh, so even the simplest pies are delectable. I love their pizza bianca with just a little olive oil and fresh rosemary. It’s so light and flavorful, and it’s the ideal meal for people who want a piece of pizza that isn’t too heavy.


2. Upside Pizza 

598 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (646)484-5244
Visit Website

Upside Pizza is right across the street from the Holiday Inn New York City and features some of the best pizza in Hell’s Kitchen, or maybe even in New York City in general.

One thing that Upside Pizza does extraordinarily well is perfect old-world flavors. For example, their pepperoni pizza tastes like it’s right out of Italy, with an excellent sauce, cheese, and dough balance.

Not only is it authentic, but it’s very affordable too, and you can expect fast friendly service. Other standout items include their Sicilian slice and cheese pizzas.  


1. Don Antonio by Starita

309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (646) 719-1043
Visit Website

Down the street from the Gershwin Theatre, you’ll find Don Antonio by Starita. This Hell’s Kitchen favorite serves inventive takes on pizza, plus plenty of salads, pasta, and appetizers.

I like starting my meal with their pear salad, a well-dressed masterpiece with different flavors and textures mixed right in.

You can opt for classic pizzas or fried pizzas if you’re feeling more adventurous. I find the fried pizza to be a little too much for one person, but their traditional pizzas are light, cheesy, and packed with plenty of flavors.

If you can, save some room for dessert. Their panna cotta is excellent. 

Final Thoughts

If you are looking for an excellent place to enjoy some of New York City’s finest pizza, give these spots in Hell’s Kitchen a try.

Most of them specialize in making pizza the authentic New York way, with a very thin flavorful crust and plenty of tasty sauce and cheese. Plus, these restaurants are where the locals go to eat, so you know that they are good.

From old-world style pies to vegan and gluten-free options, Hell’s Kitchen definitely has it all. Wherever you go, you won’t leave hungry or dissatisfied. Did we miss your favorite pizza spot in Hell’s Kitchen? Let us know in the comments below. 

Lauren Peterson

Add comment

Most popular