Where To Find The Best Pizza in Tribeca, NYC

Tribeca is one of New York City’s hippest and most exciting neighborhoods, full of cobblestone streets, great shopping, and plenty of things to do and see. Tribeca has been part of the beating heart of New York City for over a century. It is famous for its cultural contributions like the renowned Tribeca Film Festival and many museums. There’s also plenty of Tribeca pizza places drawing crowds in this NYC neighborhood!

American pizza with pepperoni

One of the most interesting destinations in Tribeca is the Dream House, an immersive, interactive exhibit that will challenge all of your senses. You can also check out the iconic Ghostbuster’s Firehouse. Although it’s currently a functioning firehouse, you can still get some great pictures outside.

If you’re looking for some good souvenirs, Tribeca is an excellent spot to go. Boutiques line its idyllic streets, and you’re bound to find something for everyone on your list. Of course, there are also some great restaurants in Tribeca, specifically authentic New York City pizza parlors, that are sure to satisfy even picky eaters.

From traditional pies to unique toppings and preparations, Tribeca has it all. Check out my list of the top nine best pizza parlors in Tribeca below!

Tribeca’s Best Pizza

  1. Il Mattone
  2. Saluggi’s
  3. Little Italy Pizza
  4. Kesté Pizza & Vino
  5. Rubirosa
  6. Joe’s Pizza
  7. John’s of Bleecker St.
  8. Gran Morsi
  9. Adoro Lei

Il Mattone

49 Beach St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (646) 964-4623
Visit Website

Just steps away from St. John’s Park, you’ll find II Mattone. This restaurant is easily one of my favorite pizza places in Tribeca, serving up excellent calzones and pizzas by the slice or entire pie.

You really can’t get more authentic than II Mattone. Even their more humble pies are outstanding. I personally like their cheese and margarita pizzas.

If you’re extra hungry, get a side of sausage rolls with your pizza. The dough is springy, fresh, flavorful, and compliments the sausage perfectly.

Next time you find yourself in Tribeca, II Mattone is a must-visit pizza parlor. 


Saluggi’s

325 Church St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 226-7900
Visit Website

Saluggi’s is a few blocks away from the Sheraton Tribeca and is a fun local haunt with friendly service and outstanding food.

Although you can certainly get excellent pizza at Saluggi’s, I like their pasta. The penne with vodka sauce is delicious and tastes almost like homemade. Saluggi’s is a great place to go on a chilly evening or after a long day of sightseeing.

If you like meatballs, this is the spot for you. Their meatballs are hearty, perfectly spiced, and go well with one of Saluggi’s signature pies or pasta.

You won’t regret giving this iconic Tribeca pizza parlor a try. 


Little Italy Pizza

11 Park Pl, New York, NY 10007
Phone: (212) 227-7077
Visit Website

With a name like Little Italy Pizza, you know this restaurant has to be good, and it certainly doesn’t disappoint. A few blocks away from New York City Hall, Little Italy Pizza is an excellent place to get slices or whole pies.

There’s also a vast selection of different classic and signature pizzas, including chicken parmesan, lasagna, and bruschetta. 

The portions at Little Italy Pizza are no joke either. One slice is more than enough to fill up most people, and you can easily share a pie with your whole family.

You certainly get what you pay for and will leave satisfied.


Kesté Pizza & Vino

66 Gold St, New York, NY 10038
Phone: (212) 243-1500
Visit Website

Next to DeLury Square, you will find Keste Pizza & Vino, an iconic New York pizza parlor and the place to get some of the best pizza in Tribeca.

Although the pizza is definitely the star of the show, Keste Pizza & Vino serves up some great traditional meatballs too. Their meatballs are beefy and full of lots of spices. Their burrata is exceptional also.

As far as pizzas go, I love the mozzarella and prosciutto pie. It’s piled high with creamy cheese and plenty of salty prosciutto for a flavor combination that you just can’t beat.

If you’re feeling a little bit more adventurous, check out their pistachio and salsiccia pie with pistachio pesto and two different types of cheeses.


Rubirosa

235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012
Phone: (212) 965-0500
Visit Website

Hungry diners can find Rubirosa just two blocks from the Basilica of St. Patricks on Mulberry Street. This famous Tribeca icon has a huge spread of different pizzas, plus appetizers, antipasto, and flavorful pasta dishes.

I love the manicotti antipasto and butternut squash tortellini personally, but the supremo pizza is the best reason to visit Rubirosa.

Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and plenty of cheese, the Rubirosa is an exemplary pie that’s big enough to feed just about everyone in your entire family. You certainly won’t leave unsatisfied. 


Joe’s Pizza

124 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038
Phone: (212) 267-0860
Visit Website

Joe’s Pizza is just a few minutes away from Millennium Park and is a local treasure that not too many tourists know about. Their pizzas have the traditional New York thin crust, with a generous serving of sauce and lots of cheese.

If you like your pizza to be as authentic as possible and want to dine in a very local establishment, get to Joe’s Pizza. 

When it comes to Joe’s Pizza, I tend to be a purist. I really like their cheese pie and their simple pepperoni slice. Sometimes the simplest toppings are the best, especially when your pie hits all of the high notes with flavor.


John’s of Bleecker St.

278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 243-1680
Visit Website

John’s of Bleecker Street is about two blocks from the Christopher Street Station Metro and is famous for its amazing sauce. They get all of the spices down perfectly, striking the right balance between sweet, spicy, and zesty.

If the sauce is what gets people in the door at John’s of Bleecker Street, the crust is what keeps them coming back. It’s crispy, doughy, and gorgeous. 

Their pepperoni pizza is excellent, with a generous serving of meat on every slice. In addition, you will find a robust beer selection of local and regional brews if you dine in.


Gran Morsi

22 Warren St, New York, NY 10007
Phone: (212) 577-2725
Visit Website

Steps away from the Chamber Street metro, hungry visitors will find Gran Morsi, one of Tribeca’s best pizzerias. Gran Morsi tends to be pretty popular, especially on the weekends, so make sure you get reservations if you’re going on a Friday or Saturday night.

One thing that Gran Morsi is known for is its inventive pies. I love their mushroom pizza, loaded with all sorts of different kinds of mushrooms and baked to perfection.

The chicken parmigiana pie is good too, and their pasta dishes are excellent. Try the tagliatelle pasta. It’s light, flavorful, and wonderfully prepared. 


Adoro Lei

287 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (646) 666-5096
Visit Website

If you visit the New York City Fire Museum on your Tribeca travels, make sure that you check out Adoro Lei. It’s right across the street and a great place to swing in for a slice or entire pizza pie.

First, the service is exceptional. The staff at Adoro Lei is friendly, accommodating, and really knowledgeable about their menu.

Then, there’s the food itself. The plethora of different options range from pizzas to salads to pasta. I love their spin on a caesar salad. It’s full of parmesan cheese, freshly baked croutons, and flavorful dressing. Their meatball pizza is next-level delicious as well.


Final Thoughts

From traditional old-world style pizza to new favorites, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your appetite in Tribeca. These nine pizza parlors serve up some of the best pies in the entire city and are all local favorites with huge followings. So if you want to eat like a New Yorker, you should definitely put one of these places on your “must visit” list.

How did we do? Are we missing your favorite pizza parlor? Let us know where the best place to get a slice of pizza or pie in Tribeca is in the comments below.

Add comment

Most popular